Too Fast, Too Furious? Algorithmic Trading and Financial Instability

Lise Arena, Nathalie Oriol, Iryna Veryzhenko

Abstract


To what extent can algorithmic trading-based strategies explain the propagation of flash crashes on financial markets? This question has to be discussed at the intersection of two disciplinary fields: management of information systems and finance. Built on realistic assumptions on traders’ strategies, on their use of algorithmic information systems and considering the role of transactions systems at the market level, an agent-based approach is presented. Final results show that speed-oriented trading strategies and the increasing use of new trading technologies can arm markets’ stability and resiliency, facing intraday operational shocks. The article also shows the central role played by transactions systems in the propagation of flash crashes, when a new regulation based on the principle of decimalization is introduced.


Keywords


High frequency trading strategies, Flash crash, Information technologies, Agent-based approach.

Full Text:

 Subscribers Only

References


Arena L., Oriol N. et Pastorelli I., (2013), « Systèmes d’information et gestion du couple performance/ sécurité : Trajectoires comparées de trois situations extrêmes », Systèmes d’Information et Management, Vol. 18, n°1, p. 87-123.

Autorité des Marchés Financiers, (2017), « Comportement des traders à haute fréquence sur Euronext Paris », [http://www.amf-France.org]

Beaufils B., Brandouy O., Ma L. et Matthieu P., (2009), « Simuler pour comprendre : un éclairage sur les dynamiques de marchés financiers à l’aide des systèmes multi-agents », Systèmes d’Information et Management, Vol. 14, n°4, p. 51-70.

Bérard C., (2009), Le processus de décision dans les systèmes complexes : Une analyse d’une intervention systémique, Thèse de Doctorat en Sciences de Gestion, Université Paris-Dauphine et Université du Québec à Montréal.

Bernile G., Hu J., Tang Y., (2016), « Can Information be Locked-up ? Informed Trading Ahead of Macro-News Announcements », Journal of Financial Economics, n°121, p. 496–520.

Boehmer E., Fong K. Y. L., Wu, J., (2015), “International Evidence on Algorithmic Trading”, AFA San Diego Meetings Paper. Disponible sur SSRN: [https://ssrn.com/abstract=2022034]

Brandouy O., Mathieu P. et Veryzhenko I., (2013), « On the Design of Agent-Based Artificial Stock Markets », Communications in Computer and Information Science, Vol. 271, p.350-364

Brewer P., Cvitanic J. et Plott C.R., (2013), « Market Microstructure Design and Flash Crashes: A Simulation Approach », Journal of Applied Economics, Vol. 16, n°2, p. 223-250.

Brock W. et Hommes C., (1997), «A Rational Route to Randomness», Econometrica, n°65, p. 1059-1095.

Brogaard J., Carrion A., Moyaert T., Riordan R., Shkilko A., Sokolov K., (2016), High-Frequency Trading and Extreme Price Movements, working paper.

Brogaard J., Hendershott T. et Riordan R., (2014), “High-Frequency Trading and Price Discovery”, Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 27, n°8, p. 2267-2306.

Cartier M., (2003), La dynamique de l’adaptation d’industries : Simulation par algorithme génétique, Thèse de Doctorat en Sciences de Gestion, Université Paris-Dauphine.

Cartier M. et Forgues B., (2006), « Intérêt de la simulation pour les sciences de gestion », Revue Française de Gestion, Vol. 6, n°165, p. 125-137.

Challet, D., Marsili, M. et Zhang, Y-C., (2005), Minority Games: Interacting Agents in Financial Markets, Oxford University Press.

Clemons, E.K. et Weber B.W., (1996), “Alternative securities trading systems: tests and regulatory implications of the adoption of technology”, Information Systems Research, Vol. 7, n°2, p. 163-188

Cliff D., Northrop L. (2011), “The Global Financial Markets: An Ultra-Large-Scale Systems Perspective”, UK Government Office for Science, 2011. 47 p.

Davis, J.P., Eisenhardt K.M., Bingham C.B., (2007), “Developing Theory through Simulation Methods”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 32, n°2, p. 480-499.

Derveeuw J., Beaufils B., Mathieu P., Brandouy O., (2007), « Un modèle d'interaction réaliste pour la simulation de marchés financiers », Annales du Lamsade, n°8.

Dodd R., (2010), « Opaque Trades », Finance and development, p. 26-28.

Dooley K.J., (2002), « Simulation Research Methods », in Baum (ed.), Companion to Organizations, p. 829-848.

Foucault T., (2016), « Quels sont les risques du trading haute-fréquence ? », Revue de la stabilité financière, n°20, p. 63-78.

Francis, J. C., Toy, W. W., Whittaker, J. G. (2000). The Handbook of equity derivatives. Revised Edition. Wiley. 720p.

Frankel, J. A., Froot K.A., (1987), “Using Survey Data to Test Standard Propositions Regarding Exchange Rate Expectations”, American Economic Review, Vol. 77, n°1, p. 133-153.

Godechot O., Hassoun, J-P., Muniesa, F., (2000), « La volatilité des postes. Professionnels des marchés et informatisation », Actes de la recherche en Sciences Sociales, Vol. 134, p. 45-55.

Graham B. et Dodd D., (1934), Security Analysis, McGraw-Hill.

Hagströmer B. et Nordén L., (2013), “The Diversity of High-Frequency Traders”, Journal of Financial Markets, Vol.16, n°4, p. 741-770.

Hendershott T., Jones C., Menkveld A. J., (2011), “Does Algorithmic Trading Improve Liquidity?”, The Journal of Finance, Vo. 66, p. 1-33

Hendershott, T., Moulton P.C., (2011), “Automation, speed, and stock market quality: The NYSE's Hybrid”, Journal of Financial Markets, Vol. 14, n°4, p.568-604

Hendershott, T., Riordan, R. (2013), “Algorithmic Trading and the Market for Liquidity”, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol. 48, n°4, p. 1001-1024

Jain, P., (2005), “Financial Market Design and the Equity Premium: Electronic versus Floor Trading.” Journal of Finance, 60, 2955–2985.

Kauffman R.J., Liu J., Ma D., (2015), “Innovations in financial IS and technology ecosystems: High-frequency trading in the equity market”, Technological Forecasting & Social Change, n° 99, p. 339–354.

Knorr-Cetina K., Preda A., (2012), The Oxford Handbook of the Sociology of Finance, Oxford University Press.

Kurov A., Sancetta A., Strasser G., (2016), “Price drift before U.S. macroeconomic news: Private information about public announcements?”, Working paper series, n°1901, European Central Bank, Eurosystem.

Liarte S., (2005), Stratégies d’implantation et interactions concurrentielles : le cas des entreprises multi-unités multi-marchés, Thèse de Doctorat en Sciences de Gestion, Université Paris-Dauphine.

McGowan M. J., (2010), « The Rise of Computerized High Frequency Trading : Use and Controversy », Duke Law and Technology Review, n°16, p. 1-24.

MacKenzie D., (2014), A Sociology of Algorithms: High-Frequency Trading and the Shaping of Markets, Manuscrit non publié.

McKelvey B., (2002), « Model-Centered Organization Science Epistemology », in Baum, (ed.), Companion to Organizations, p. 752-780.

Menkhoff, L., Sarno L., Schmeling M., Schrimpf A., (2012): “Currency Momentum Strategies”, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 106, n°3, p. 660-684.

Nassirtoussi A.K., Aghabozorgi S., Wah T.Y., Ling Ngo D.C., (2014) « Text Mining for Market Prediction: A Systematic Review », Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 41, n° 16, p. 7653-7670.

Preda, A., (2006), “Socio-technical Agency in Financial Markets: The Case of the Stock Ticker”, Social Studies of Science, Vol. 36, n°5, p. 753-782.

Roy B., (2002), « L’aide à la décision aujourd’hui : que devrait-on attendre ? », in David, Hatchuel, Laufer, Les nouvelles fondations des sciences de gestion, p. 141-174.

Seyfert R., (2016), “Bugs, Predations or Manipulations? Incompatible Epistemic Regimes of High-Frequency Trading”, Economy & Society, Vol. 45, n°2, p. 251-277.

Shabbir T., (2015), “High-Frequency Trading: Implications for Market Efficiency and Fairness, In The Handbook of High Frequency Trading, édité par Greg N. Gregoriou,, Academic Press, San Diego, p. 113-122

Shatner M., Mushnik L. et Solomon S. (2000), “A continuous time asynchronous model of the stock market”, Preprint submitted to Elsevier Preprint.

Sommerville I., Cliff D., Calinescu R., Keen J., Kelly T., Kwiatkowska M., McDermid J., Paige R., (2012), “Large-scale complex IT Systems”, in Communications of the ACM, Vol. 55, n°7, p. 71-77.

Taylor, M., Allen H., (1992), “The Use of Technical Analysis in the Foreign Exchange Market”, Journal of International Money and Finance, Vol. 11, n°3, p. 304-314.

Veryzhenko I., Arena L., Harb E., Oriol N., (2016), “A Reexamination of High Frequency Trading Regulation Effectiveness in an Artificial Market Framework” in Trends in Practical Applications of Scalable Multi-Agent Systems, the PAAMS Collection, F. de la Prieta, M.J. Escalona, R. Corchuelo, P. Mathieu, Z. Vale, A.T. Campbell, S. Rossi, E. Adam, M.D. Jiménez-Lopez, E.M. Navarro, M.N. Moreno (Eds), Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing Series, Springer, Vol. 473, p. 15-25.

Weber B.W., (1999), “Next-generation trading in futures markets: A comparison of open outcry and order matching systems”, Journal of Management Information Systems, Vol. 16, n°2, p. 29-45.

Ye M., Yao C., Gai, J., (2013), “The Externalities of High Frequency Trading”, Disponible sur SSRN: [https://ssrn.com/abstract=2066839]




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.9876/sim.v23i2.856

Copyright (c) 2018 Systèmes d'Information et Management (French Journal of Management Information Systems)