Symbolic Transformation for ERP appropriation



Despite research showing the transformational nature of Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), developers and implementers tend to impose “best way":  a standard ERP based on best practices, top-down approach, and implementation in a “vanilla". These practices convey different myths: the "myth of the standard", the "leadership of the information technology staff", or the resistance to be eradicated. Users may interpret these practices as a "symbol", a means of imposing new ways of working removed from their local practices, which provoke resistance and conflicts that generally lead to low appropriation of the ERP, or even to failure. Hirschheim and Newman’s research on the symbolic of information systems (IS) is little mobilized in ERP literature and more generally IS, while their concept of “enabling symbolic” opens perspectives to support ERP appropriation. The action research conducted for two years by one of the researchers, an ERP project manager in charge of the ERP deployment within a European group of small subsidiaries, constitutes an opportunity to try to fill this void or theoretical gap. The results help to deepen the various re/shaping symbolic devices necessary to evolve towards an enabling symbolic and support ERP appropriation. The research also highlights conditions unidentified in the literature for symbolic transformation, such as structured autonomy, and the role of the project manager as a boundary actor.


Information systems; ERP; Symbolic; Appropriation; Re/shaping symbolic devices


Adler, P.S., Borys, B. (1996), "Two types of bureaucracy: enabling and coercive", Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 41, n°1, p. 61 89.

Ahmad, M. M., Cuenca, R. P. (2013), "Critical success factors for ERP implementation in SMEs", Robotics and Computer-integrated Manufacturing, Vol. 29, n°3, p. 104-111.

Albarakati, A.J. (2015), "Enterprise Resource Planning Execution/ Implementation Methodology Classification", International Journal of Applied Information Systems, Vol. 8, n°5, p. 20-24.

Ali, M., Zhou, L., Miller, L., Ieromonachou, P. (2016), "User resistance in IT: A literature review", International Journal of Information Management, Vol. 36, n°1, p. 35-43.

Allard-Poesi, F., Perret, V. (2003), "La recherche-action", in Conduire un projet de recherche, une perspective qualitative, Y. Giordano (Ed.), Collection Management et Société, EMS, Paris, p. 85-132.

Barrett, F., Thomas, G., Hocevar, S. (1995), "The central role of discourse in large-scale change : A social construction perspective", Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, Vol. 31, n°3, p. 352-372.

Baskerville, R.L. (1999), "Investigating information systems with action research", Communications of the Association for Information Systems, Vol. 2, n°19, p. 32.

Besson, P. (1999), "Les ERP à l’épreuve de l’organisation", Systèmes d’Information et Management, Vol.4, n°4, p.21-52.

Besson, P., Rowe, F. (2011), "Perspectives sur le phénomène de la transformation organisationnelle", Systèmes d’Information et Management, Vol. 16, n°1, p. 3-34.

Bloch, A., Nabat, E. (2009), "Pérennité organisationnelle et transformation. Concilier l’inconciliable ? ", Revue Française de Gestion, Vol. 35, n°192, p.113-126.

Botta-Genoulaz, V., Millet, P.A., Grabot, B. (2005), "A Survey on the Recent Literature on ERP Systems", Computers in Industry, Vol. 56, n°6, p. 510-522.

Callon, M, Latour, B. (1991), La science telle qu’elle se fait, Paris, Éditions La Découverte.

Charreire-Petit, S., Durieux, F. (2014), "Explorer et tester : les deux voies de la recherche", in Méthodes de recherche en management, R.A. Thiétart (Ed.), Dunod, Paris, p. 76-104.

Chiasson, M., Germonprez, M. et Mathiassen, L. (2009), "Pluralist action research : a review of the information systems literature", Information Systems Journal, Vol. 19, n°1, p. 31-54.

Davenport, T. H., Stoddard, D. B. (1994), "Reengineering: business change of mythic proportions? ", MIS Quarterly, Vol. 18, n°2, p. 121-127.

Davison, R.M., Martinsons, M.G., Kock, N. (2004), "Principles of canonical action research", Information Systems Journal, Vol. 14, n°1, p. 65-86.

De Sanctis, G., Poole, M. S. (1994), "Capturing the complexity in advanced technology use: Adaptive structuration theory", Organization Science, Vol. 5, n°2, p.121-147.

De Vaujany, F.-X. (2005a), "De la pertinence d’une réflexion sur le management de l’appropriation des objets et outils de gestion", in De la conception à l’usage : vers un management de l’appropriation des outils de gestion, F.-X. De Vaujany (Ed.), Collection Management et Société, EMS, Paris.

De Vaujany, F.-X. (2005b), "La gestion stratégique des technologies de l’information : contextualisation de la littérature par une expérience imaginaire", Management International, Vol. 9, n°4, p. 1-16.

De Vaujany, F.-X. (2006), "Pour une théorie de l’appropriation des outils de gestion : vers un dépassement de l’opposition conception-usage", Management & Avenir, Vol. 9, n°3, p.109 126.

Ducray, L. (2015), "Retour d'expérience d'implantation de quatre outils de rationalisation productive (ERP) sous l'éclairage de la théorie de la régulation sociale", RIMHE : Revue Interdisciplinaire Management, Homme(s) & Entreprise, Vol. 2, n°16, p. 94-113.

Dudézert, A., Fayard, P., Oiry, E. (2015), "Astérix et la gestion des connaissances 2.0 : une exploration de l’appropriation des SGC 2.0 par le mythe du village gaulois", Systèmes d’Information & Management, Vol. 20, n°1, p. 31 59.

Dudézert, A., Portal, M. (2016), La controverse dans l'appropriation des outils de gestion : contes de connaissance, L'Harmattan, Paris.

Earl, M. (1983), Perspectives on Management, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

El Amrani R., Saint-Léger G. (2013), "Etats des lieux de la recherche ERP francophone", Systèmes d’Information et Management, Vol. 18, n°2, p. 111-160.

Ford, J. D., Ford, L. W., D’Amelio, A. (2008), "Resistance to Change: The Rest of the Story", Academy of Management Review, Vol. 33, n°2, p. 362-377.

Geffroy Maronnat, B. (2010), "ERP et dynamique sociale de l’intégration", Management & Avenir, Vol. 9, n° 39, p. 233-249.

Grabski, S.V., Leech, S.A., Schmidt, P.J. (2011), “A review of ERP research: A future agenda for accounting information systems”, Journal of Information Systems, Vol. 25, n°1, p. 37-78.

Grimand, A. (2011), "Les outils de gestion comme vecteurs de construction de sens : une relecture à travers l’oeuvre de Karl Weick", in Valeurs et outils de gestion : de la dynamique d’appropriation à leur pilotage, C. Dominguez-Péry (Ed.), Lavoisier : Hermes science, Paris, p. 59 81.

Grimand, A. (2012), "L'appropriation des outils de gestion et ses effets sur les dynamiques organisationnelles : le cas du déploiement d'un référentiel des emplois et des compétences", Management & Avenir, n° 4, p. 237-257.

Grimand, A. (2016), "Gaston, la mouette et le gestionnaire: une relecture des controverses nées de la rencontre entre outils de gestion et organisation", in La controverse dans l'appropriation des outils de gestion: contes de connaissance, A. Dudézert et M. Portal (Eds), L'Harmattan, Paris, p. 149-166.

Hirschheim, R.A. (1986), "The effect of a priori views on the social implications of computing: the case of office automation", ACM Computing Surveys, Vol. 18, n°2, p. 165 195.

Hirschheim, R.A., Newman, M. (1991), "Symbolism and information systems development: myth, metaphor and magic", Information Systems Research, Vol. 2, n°1, p. 29 62.

Kim, W. C., Mauborgne, R. A. (2003), "Tipping point leadership", Harvard Business Review, Vol. 81, n°3, p. 60-69.

Lanzara, G.F., Mathiassen, L. (1985), "Mapping situations within a system development project", Information & Management, Vol. 8, n°1, p. 3 20.

Laumer, S., Eckhardt, A. (2012), "Why Do People Reject Technologies: A Review of User Resistance Theories", in Information Systems Theory, Y. K. Dwivedi, M. R. Wade and S. L. Schneberger (Eds), Springer, New York, p. 63-86.

Lawrence, P., Lorsch, J. (1989), Adapter les structures de l’entreprise, Les Editions d’Organisation, Paris.

Leonardi, P.M. (2013), "Theoretical foundations for the study of sociomateriality", Information and Organization, Vol. 23, n° 2, p. 59-76.

Lindgren, R., Henfridsson, O., Schultze, U. (2004), "Design principles for competence management systems: a synthesis of an action research study", MIS Quarterly, Vol. 28, n°3, p. 435-472.

Loh, T.C., Koh, S. (2004), "Critical elements for a successful enterprise resource planning implementation in small and medium sized enterprises", International Journal of Production Research, Vol. 42, n°17, p. 3433-3455.

Lyytinen, K., Newman, M., Al-Muharfi, A. R. (2009), "Institutionalizing enterprise resource planning in the Saudi steel industry: a punctuated socio-technical analysis", Journal of Information Technology, Vol. 24, n°4, p. 286-304.

Markus, M. L. (1983), "Power, Politics and MIS Implementation", Communications of the ACM, Vol. 26, n° 6, p. 430-444.

Meissonier, R., Houzé, E. (2010), "Toward an ‘IT conflict-resistance theory’: action research during it pre-implementation", European Journal of Information Systems, Vol. 19, n°5, p. 540 561.

Meissonier, R., Houze, E., Bessiere, V. (2013), "Cross-cultural friction in information systems management: research perspectives on ERP implementation misfits in Thailand", International Business Research, Vol. 6, n°2, p.150-159.

Mintzberg, H. (1994), The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning, Prentice Hall, New York.

Morgan, G. (1989), Images de l’organisation, ESKA, Paris.

Morin, E. (1977), La Méthode. La Nature de la Nature, Editions du Seuil, Paris.

Ng, C.S.P. (2011), "Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) upgrade decision: Toward a unified view", 7th Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems, pp.1039- 1054, AIS Electronic library, Adelaide, Australia.

Ng, M.M., Tan, M.T. (2004), "Symbolic processes in ERP versus legacy system usage", in Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice, B. Kaplan, D. P. Truex, D. Wastell, A. T. Wood-Harper, & J. I. DeGross (Eds), MA, Springer US, Boston, p. 713 722.

Olson, D.L, Staley, J. (2012), "Case study of open-source enterprise resource planning implementation in a small business", Enterprise Information Systems, Vol. 6, n° 1, p. 79-94.

Orlikowski, W.J. (2007), "Sociomaterial Practices: Exploring Technology at Work", Organization Studies, Vol. 28, n°9, p. 1435-1448.

Piderit, S. K. (2000), "Rethinking resistance and recognizing ambivalence: A multidimensional view of attitudes toward an organizational change", Academy of Management Review, Vol. 25, n°4, p.783-794.

Poba-Nzaou, P., Raymond, L. (2011), "Managing ERP system risk in SMEs: A multiple case study", Journal of Information Technology, Vol. 26, n°3, p. 170-192.

Robey, D., Markus, M. (1984), "Rituals in Information System Design", MIS Quarterly, Vol. 8, n°1, p. 5-15.

Rousseau, D. (1996), "Changing the deal while keeping the people", Academy of Management Executive, Vol. 10, n°1, p.50-59.

Royer, I., Zarlowski, P. (2014), Le design de la recherche, in Méthodes de recherche en management, R.A. Thiétard (Ed.), Dunod, Paris, p. 168-198.

Shehab, E. M., Sharp, M. W., Supramaniam, L., Spedding, T. A. (2004), “Enterprise resource planning: An integrative review”, Business Process Management Journal, Vol. 10, n°4, p. 359-386.

Simoes, P. M., Esposito, M. (2014), “Improving change management: how communication nature influences resistance to change”, Journal of Management Development, Vol. 33, n°4, p. 324-34.

Smith, W.K., Tushman, M.L. (2005), “Managing strategic contradictions: A top management model for managing innovation streams”, Organization Science, Vol. 16, n° 5, p. 522-536.

Smith, W. K., Lewis, M. W. (2011), “Toward a theory of paradox: A dynamic equilibrium model of organizing”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 36, n°2, p. 381-403.

Snider, B., da Silveira, G.J., Balakrishnan, J. (2009), "ERP implementation at SMEs: analysis of five Canadian cases", International Journal of Operations & Production Management, Vol. 29, n°1, p. 4-29.

Somers, T., Nelson, K. (2001), "The Impact of Critical Success Factors across the Stages of Enterprise Resource Planning Implementations", In Proceedings of the 34th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, p. 10.

Susman, G.I., Evered R.D. (1978), "An assessment of the scientific merits of action research", Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 23, n°4, p. 582-603.

Trice, H., Beyer, J. (1984), "Studying Organizational Cultures through Rites and Ceremonials", Academy of Management Review, Vol. 9, n°4, p. 653-669.

Upadhyay, P., Jahanyan, S., Dan, P.K. (2011), "Factors influencing ERP implementation in Indian manufacturing organisations: A study of micro, small and medium-scale enterprises", Journal of Enterprise Information Management, Vol. 24, n° 2, p. 130-145.

Villette M. (2003), Sociologie du conseil en management, La Découverte, Paris.

Wagner, E. L., Moll, J., Newell, S. (2011), "Accounting logics, reconfiguration of ERP systems and the emergence of new accounting practices: A sociomaterial perspective", Management Accounting Research, Vol. 22, n° 3, p. 181-197.

Wagner, E.L., Newell, S. (2004), "‘Best’ for whom? : the tension between ‘best practice’ ERP packages and diverse epistemic cultures in a university context", The Journal of Strategic Information Systems, Vol. 13, n°4, p. 305 328.

Weick K.E. (1995), Sensemaking in Organizations, SAGE publications.


Copyright (c) 2020 Systèmes d'Information et Management (French Journal of Management Information Systems)